Transient vs Scoped vs Singleton in .NET — Simple Guide for Developers

If you’ve ever built a .NET application, you’ve likely heard about Dependency Injection (DI) — that magical system that connects all your services together without you having to manually create objects everywhere.

But there’s one question that often confuses even experienced developers:

“How long should my service live?”

Should it be Transient, Scoped, or Singleton?

At first, this might sound like a small technical setting, but in reality, it can make or break your app’s performance, memory usage, and stability.
Pick the wrong lifetime, and you could end up with memory leaks, weird bugs, or inconsistent data.
Pick the right one, and your app will run clean, fast, and predictable.

Let’s break this down — in plain English — so you’ll always know which lifetime to choose.

---

🚗 Understanding Service Lifetimes (Think of It Like Renting a Vehicle)

Imagine you’re renting vehicles for different tasks:

Analogy	Lifetime	Description
🚴‍♂️ A bike for a quick, one-time ride	Transient	Cheap, short-lived
🚗 A car you keep for the entire day	Scoped	Shared during one trip/request
🚌 A bus that keeps running for everyone all day	Singleton	Shared globally

In .NET, service lifetimes decide how long a service object exists before the DI container replaces or disposes it.

You choose this when registering your service using:

AddTransient()
AddScoped()
AddSingleton()

Each tells .NET how long to keep an instance around — and who gets to reuse it.

---

💡 Why Service Lifetime Matters

Every time your app injects a service, the DI container must decide whether to:

• 🆕 Create a new instance
• 🔁 Reuse an existing one
• 🌍 Share one across the entire application

That small choice impacts memory usage, performance, and thread safety.

If you choose incorrectly:

• You might reuse data that shouldn’t be shared.
• You might waste memory creating too many objects.
• You might get runtime errors (like injecting a Scoped service into a Singleton).

Choosing the right lifetime means your services behave consistently and efficiently — no surprises in production.

---

⚡ Transient — “New Every Time”

A Transient service is created every time it’s requested.
No caching, no reuse.

Think of it like getting a brand-new disposable pen every time you need to write something — simple, stateless, and cheap.

🧱 Registering a Transient Service

builder.Services.AddTransient<IEmailSender, SmtpEmailSender>();

✅ When to Use It

• For stateless services (no internal data to share)
• Lightweight utilities like validators, mappers, or string formatters
• When each call should get a clean instance

⚠️ Watch Out For

• Don’t use it for heavy or expensive services — it’ll slow you down.
• If it uses unmanaged resources, ensure it’s properly disposed.

Use Transient when you don’t care about reusing instances — just quick, clean, and independent.

---

🔄 Scoped — “One Per Request”

A Scoped service is created once per scope — usually one per HTTP request.
All parts of that request share the same instance, but the next request gets a fresh one.

Think of it like renting a car for a day — you can use it throughout the trip, but it’s returned and reset after.

🧱 Registering a Scoped Service

builder.Services.AddScoped<IUserContext, HttpUserContext>();

✅ When to Use It

• For request-specific logic — like user context or request data
• Services that depend on the current user, transaction, or DbContext
• Anything that needs consistency within a request but not between requests

⚠️ Watch Out For

• Never inject a Scoped service into a Singleton — it’ll crash.
• Don’t assume it’s shared across requests — it’s not.
• Dispose scopes properly if you create them manually.

Scoped is often the default choice in ASP.NET Core web apps because it fits how HTTP requests work.

---

🌍 Singleton — “One for the Whole App”

A Singleton service is created once and shared everywhere for the entire lifetime of the app.

Think of it like a bus that runs for everyone — all requests, all users — forever.

🧱 Registering a Singleton Service

builder.Services.AddSingleton<IClock, SystemClock>();

✅ When to Use It

• For global, stateless, and thread-safe services
• Logging, configuration providers, or caching layers
• Background tasks or system-wide helpers

⚠️ Watch Out For

• Don’t inject Scoped services into a Singleton.
• Be careful with shared state — if mutable, make it thread-safe.
• Avoid heavy dependencies or disposable objects unless you manage cleanup manually.

Singletons offer great performance — but with great power comes great responsibility.

---

🧭 Real-World Examples

Lifetime	Example Service	Why It Fits
Transient	IEmailBuilder, IPasswordHasher	Cheap, stateless utilities
Scoped	DbContext, IUserContext, IUnitOfWork	Request-specific data
Singleton	ILogger<T>, IClock, ICacheService	Global, thread-safe logic

Always ask yourself:

“Does this service hold per-request data, or can it be shared safely?”

That question alone will guide most lifetime decisions.

---

❌ Common Mistakes (and How to Avoid Them)

Mistake	Why It’s Bad	How to Fix
Injecting Scoped into Singleton	Causes runtime errors	Use IServiceScopeFactory to resolve Scoped services
Making Singletons Stateful	Causes race conditions	Keep them stateless or thread-safe
Overusing Transient	Hurts performance	Use for lightweight, stateless logic only
Forgetting to Dispose	Memory leaks	Dispose services you create manually
Assuming Scoped Works Everywhere	Breaks in background jobs	Create scopes manually outside HTTP contexts

---

🧩 How .NET Handles Lifetimes Internally

Here’s a simplified look under the hood:

1. Registration — Each AddTransient, AddScoped, or AddSingleton call registers a ServiceDescriptor in the DI container.
2. Resolution — The DI system checks whether to create, reuse, or share an instance.
3. Scope — ASP.NET Core creates one scope per HTTP request.
4. Disposal — Scoped services are disposed at the end of each request; Singletons on app shutdown.
5. Thread Safety — The DI container itself is thread-safe, but your services need to be too.

Most of the time, you won’t need to worry about this — but knowing how it works helps you debug tricky “why is my service reused?” issues.

---

🏆 Best Practices for Choosing the Right Lifetime

✅ Keep Singletons stateless and thread-safe
✅ Use Scoped for anything tied to a request or unit of work
✅ Use Transient for small, stateless utilities
✅ Avoid mixing lifetimes incorrectly
✅ Dispose of services properly when you create them manually

A good rule of thumb:

Data Lifespan	Recommended Lifetime
Per request	Scoped
Global	Singleton
Temporary	Transient

Match the lifetime to the data’s lifespan.

---

🧾 Summary

Service lifetimes are one of the simplest yet most critical concepts in .NET Dependency Injection.

Lifetime	Description	Ideal Use
Transient	New instance every time	Lightweight, stateless services
Scoped	One instance per request	Request-specific services
Singleton	One instance for the app	Global, stateless, thread-safe services

Choosing wisely keeps your app fast, reliable, and bug-free — while making your codebase easier to test and maintain.